Blog Post

5 Performance Measurement Methodologies to Master After-Tax Benchmarking

You're reading:

5 Performance Measurement Methodologies to Master After-Tax Benchmarking

Alex Serman • October 26, 2023

For many wealth management firms, assessing investment performance is already a manual and intricate process. However, the introduction of tax-optimization takes this complexity to an entirely new level. Measuring after-tax performance for investments necessitates grappling with a myriad of factors, ranging from tax rules and rates to individual investor circumstances. Although traditional performance measurements often overlook the impact of taxes, the truth is that taxes can wield a significant influence on investment returns. Overlooking these implications can lead to distorted evaluations of investment attractiveness and growth potential. This article will delve into the intricacies of measuring after-tax performance, explore advanced methodologies, highlight their benefits, and emphasize the importance of tax efficiency in investment management. Specifically, how benchmarks can be created and utilized to provide realistic comparisons to the market on an after-tax basis.


1. Client-Specific Simulated Benchmark

    Client-specific simulated benchmarking represents a sophisticated approach to investment performance evaluation. This method tailors the benchmark to an individual client's tax situation, considering their unique tax liabilities, investment strategy, and time horizons. This approach offers a personalized and accurate representation of the client's investment journey by simulating how the investment would perform after accounting for taxes, including capital gains and income taxes. The client gains insights into how their investment choices would fare under their specific tax circumstances, empowering them to make well-informed decisions that align with their financial objectives. This level of transparency and customization enhances the client's understanding of their portfolio's performance and establishes a deeper level of trust between the wealth manager and their clients.

    2. Shadow Portfolio Approach

      The shadow portfolio approach introduces a highly effective method of evaluating investment performance within the context of real-world tax implications. This approach involves creating a hypothetical portfolio, known as a "shadow portfolio," that mirrors the client's actual investment holdings. By incorporating actual tax rules and rates, the shadow portfolio simulates the impact of taxes on investment returns. This enables investors to gauge the effects of taxes on their portfolio's growth over time. The shadow portfolio approach offers a clear and transparent view of how taxes can affect returns, providing investors with actionable insights to optimize their investment strategies. Through this technique, wealth managers can offer clients a more comprehensive understanding of their investments in a scalable way, paving the way for well-informed decisions that consider the crucial element of taxation.

      3. Formulation Approach

        The formulation approach introduces a systematic and rigorous method for assessing investment performance while accounting for the complexities of taxation. This approach involves developing mathematical formulas that incorporate tax considerations into the performance calculations. These formulas consider various tax variables, such as capital gains, dividends, and applicable tax rates, to accurately depict an investment's after-tax returns. By using a structured formulation, financial professionals can present clients with a clear breakdown of how taxes influence their investment outcomes. This approach enhances transparency and facilitates effective tax planning, allowing investors to make strategic decisions that align with their financial goals. The formulation approach empowers both investors and financial advisors to engage in more informed discussions about the real impact of taxes on investment performance.

        4. Pre-liquidation approach

          Employing the pre-liquidation approach offers a comprehensive and forward-looking method of evaluating investment performance while considering the potential tax consequences at the point of portfolio liquidation. This approach involves simulating the effects of taxes on an investment's returns under the assumption that the portfolio will be fully liquidated at a specified future date. By factoring in taxes on capital gains and other applicable taxes, this approach offers investors a clearer understanding of how their investments might perform after accounting for the eventual tax liabilities. The pre-liquidation approach facilitates proactive tax planning, enabling investors to make well-informed decisions to optimize their portfolio's performance in light of future tax obligations. This method provides insights into the impact of taxes on returns and empowers investors to navigate their investment strategies more strategically, with an eye on long-term tax efficiency.

          5. Single security investment approach

            Lastly, the single security investment approach introduces a focused and granular method of evaluating investment performance while considering the influence of taxes on individual securities. This approach involves assessing the performance of each security within a portfolio while accounting for specific tax considerations, such as capital gains and dividends. By analyzing the after-tax returns of individual securities, investors can better understand how taxes affect the performance of their overall portfolio. This approach empowers investors to make informed decisions about holding, selling, or reallocating specific securities based on their after-tax impact. The single security investment approach provides a nuanced perspective on how taxes interact with investment performance, enabling investors to fine-tune their strategies and optimize their portfolios for tax efficiency while pursuing their financial goals.

            Measuring after-tax performance is vital for wealth management firms aiming to provide accurate and holistic insights into investment performance. The intricate interplay between diverse tax regulations, changing policies, individualized circumstances, and complex investment strategies creates a landscape where accuracy requires meticulous attention. First Rate solves these challenges for wealth management firms by using our powerful and automated performance engine to execute the methodology best fit for the firm and their clients. By acknowledging these challenges and working with the right technology partner to employ advanced tools, wealth managers can navigate the complexities and provide more comprehensive and accurate for their clients that account for the impact of taxes.